Skip to main content
Hi! Sign in or registerDaily DealsBrand OutletGift CardsHelp & Contact
Sell
Watchlist
My eBay
  • Summary
  • Recently Viewed
  • Bids/Offers
  • Watchlist
  • Purchase History
  • Buy Again
  • Selling
  • Saved Feed
  • Saved Searches
  • Saved Sellers
  • My Garage
  • Sizes
  • My Collection
  • Messages
  • PSA Vault
Please sign-in to view notifications.
Loading...
eBay Home

Motors

Parts & accessoriesCars & trucksMotorcyclesOther vehicles

Clothing & Accessories

WomenMenHandbagsCollectible Sneakers

Sporting goods

Hunting EquipmentGolf EquipmentOutdoor sportsCycling Equipment

Electronics

Computers, Tablets & Network HardwareCell Phones, Smart Watches & AccessoriesVideo Games & ConsolesCameras & Photo

Business & Industrial

Modular & Pre-Fabricated BuildingsTest, Measurement & Inspection EquipmentHeavy Equipment, Parts & AttachmentsRestaurant & Food Service

Jewelry & Watches

Luxury WatchesWristwatchesFashion JewelryFine Jewelry

Collectibles & Art

Trading CardsCollectiblesCoins & Paper MoneySports Memorabilia

Home & garden

Yard, Garden & Outdoor Living ItemsTools & Workshop EquipmentHome ImprovementKitchen, Dining & Bar Supplies

Other categories

Books, Movies & MusicToys & HobbiesHealth & BeautyBaby Essentials
All BrandsAll CategoriesSeasonal Sales & Events
Advanced
Sponsored
Sponsored

Filter

    • Category

      • All
        • Selected categoryCoins & Paper Money
          • Coins: US
          • Coins: Canada
          • Coins: World
    • Price

      • Under $150.00
      • $150.00 to $350.00
      • Over $350.00
      $
      to
      $
      Please provide a valid price range
      Available inventory
      $0
      $1000+
    • Condition

      • Not Specified (89) Items (89)
    • Buying Format

    • Item Location

      • Within25 mi
    • Shipping and pickup

      • Arrives in 2-4 days
      • Free Shipping
      • Local Pickup within25 miles
    • Show only

      • Free Returns
      • Returns Accepted
      • Authorized Seller
      • Completed Items
      • Sold Items
      • Deals & Savings

85 results for -PF 1916 -Gold -Platinum (5C,5 CENT,FIVE CENT,NICKEL) ngc -pcgs -anacs

  • All
  • Auction
  • Buy It Now
  • All Listings- Filter Applied
  • Auction
  • Buy It Now
  • Any Condition- Filter Applied
  • Not Specified
  • Arrives in 2-4 days
  • Free Shipping
  • Best Match
  • Time: ending soonest
  • Time: newly listed
  • Price + Shipping: lowest first
  • Price + Shipping: highest first
  • Distance: nearest first
  • Gallery View
  • Shop on eBay
    Shop on eBay
    Opens in a new window or tab
    Brand New
    $20.00
    or Best Offer
    Sponsored
  • Shop on eBay
    Shop on eBay
    Opens in a new window or tab
    Brand New
    $20.00
    or Best Offer
    Sponsored
    • (#101478) Buffalo Nickel:  1916 NGC XF 40.  2 feathers variety (see video)
      (#101478) Buffalo Nickel: 1916 NGC XF 40. 2 feathers variety (see video)
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $189.99
      0 bids · Time left10h 17m left (Today 03:55 PM)
      $252.00
      Buy It Now
      +$4.51 delivery
      Sponsored
      brcgcoins (4,028) 100%
    • 5c SLAB 1916 P NGC MS64 BUFFALO INDIAN HEAD NICKEL FREE SHIPPING
      5c SLAB 1916 P NGC MS64 BUFFALO INDIAN HEAD NICKEL FREE SHIPPING
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $129.99
      0 bids · Time left1d 12h left (Tue, 06:36 PM)
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      blarkie (1,630) 100%
    • 1916 Buffalo Nickel : NGC MS64
      New Listing1916 Buffalo Nickel : NGC MS64
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $139.99
      0 bids · Time left6d 19h left (Mon, 12:43 AM)
      or Best Offer
      +$5.95 delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      tjscoins (32,661) 100%
    • 1916 "P" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC Unc Details #012 Uncirculated ECC&C
      1916 "P" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC Unc Details #012 Uncirculated ECC&C
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $79.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      east_coast_coin_collectables_inc (14,978) 99.9%Visit east_coast_coin_collectables_inc eBay Store!
    • 1916 "S" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC XF Details #014 Extra Fine ECC&C, Inc
      1916 "S" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC XF Details #014 Extra Fine ECC&C, Inc
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $89.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      east_coast_coin_collectables_inc (14,978) 99.9%Visit east_coast_coin_collectables_inc eBay Store!
    • 1916-S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel MS64 NGC *9009
      1916-S Indian Head Buffalo Nickel MS64 NGC *9009
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $879.00
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Direct from M Barr Coins
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      mbarrcoins (653,873) 99.9%Visit mbarrcoins eBay Store!
    • Super Nice 1916-P  buffalo nickel NGC MS-66
      Super Nice 1916-P buffalo nickel NGC MS-66
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $950.00
      or Best Offer
      +$15.00 delivery
      Sponsored
      vintagecoins31 (800) 100%
    • 1916 Canada FIVE CENTS NGC AU55 SILVER 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL NOW!
      1916 Canada FIVE CENTS NGC AU55 SILVER 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL NOW!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $69.91
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      herbscoinshop2 (6,954) 99.1%
    • 1916-D Buffalo Nickel NGC AU Details - Cleaned #2-013
      1916-D Buffalo Nickel NGC AU Details - Cleaned #2-013
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $110.00
      Buy It Now
      +$5.00 delivery
      Sponsored
      alamoheightscoinshop (27,231) 99.7%Visit alamoheightscoinshop eBay Store!
    • 1916 D Buffalo Nickel NGC AU58
      1916 D Buffalo Nickel NGC AU58
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $200.00
      or Best Offer
      +$3.99 delivery in 2-4 days
      Sponsored
      uscoins.com (59,341) 99.8%
    • 1916-P Buffalo Nickel 5C- NGC MS-63 Gorgeous Natural Toning Tons of Luster
      1916-P Buffalo Nickel 5C- NGC MS-63 Gorgeous Natural Toning Tons of Luster
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $149.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      bdoubrava12012 (7,761) 99.9%
    • 1916 D Buffalo Nickel - NGC AU58 ( 301193 )
      1916 D Buffalo Nickel - NGC AU58 ( 301193 )
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $150.00
      or Best Offer
      +$5.39 delivery
      Sponsored
      jpfcoinandcurrency (518) 99.7%
    • 1916 Canada Five Cents NGC AU53 SILVER 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL!
      1916 Canada Five Cents NGC AU53 SILVER 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $59.91
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      herbscoinshop2 (6,954) 99.1%
    • 1916 Canada Five Cents NGC AU SILVER BETTER DATE 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL!
      1916 Canada Five Cents NGC AU SILVER BETTER DATE 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $38.98
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      herbscoinshop2 (6,954) 99.1%
    • 1916 Canada Five Cents NGC AU SILVER 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL NOW!
      1916 Canada Five Cents NGC AU SILVER 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL NOW!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $49.97
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      herbscoinshop (23,982) 100%
    • 1916 P Buffalo Nickel 5c NGC MS 65 Old Holder!
      1916 P Buffalo Nickel 5c NGC MS 65 Old Holder!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $729.99
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      centurycoll (36,579) 100%
    • 1916 BUFFALO NICKEL NGC AU 58
      1916 BUFFALO NICKEL NGC AU 58
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $195.00
      or Best Offer
      +$8.00 delivery
      Sponsored
      efg1234 (2,180) 100%
    • 1916 D Buffalo Nickel NGC VF 35 Very Fine #1-027
      1916 D Buffalo Nickel NGC VF 35 Very Fine #1-027
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $69.00
      Buy It Now
      +$5.00 delivery
      Sponsored
      alamoheightscoinshop (27,231) 99.7%Visit alamoheightscoinshop eBay Store!
    • 1916 S Buffalo Nickel NGC VF 35 Very Fine #1-034
      1916 S Buffalo Nickel NGC VF 35 Very Fine #1-034
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $99.00
      Buy It Now
      +$5.00 delivery
      Sponsored
      alamoheightscoinshop (27,231) 99.7%Visit alamoheightscoinshop eBay Store!
    • 1916 "2 Feathers" Buffalo Nickel 5C BEAUTIFUL TONING, NGC AU58, Rotated Die Rev!
      1916 "2 Feathers" Buffalo Nickel 5C BEAUTIFUL TONING, NGC AU58, Rotated Die Rev!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $449.99
      Was: $499.9910% off
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      smitkis (3,080) 99%
    • 1916 D Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo NGC AU-58
      1916 D Nickel Indian Head or Buffalo NGC AU-58
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $149.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      segoja (15,948) 100%
    • 1916/16 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC G
      1916/16 5C Buffalo Nickel NGC G
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $3,000.00
      Buy It Now
      +$14.95 delivery in 2-4 days
      Sponsored
      roundtable-auctions (8,978) 99.3%Visit roundtable-auctions eBay Store!
    • 1916-D Buffalo Nickel 5C Coin. Certified NGC MS67 - RARE Top Pop 2/0 in MS67!
      1916-D Buffalo Nickel 5C Coin. Certified NGC MS67 - RARE Top Pop 2/0 in MS67!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $13,713.25
      Was: $14,435.005% off
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery in 2-4 days
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      eternitycoin (31,094) 99.9%
    • 1916 P NGC MS64 Buffalo Nickel
      1916 P NGC MS64 Buffalo Nickel
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $175.74
      Was: $184.995% off
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      coinslabz26 (11,298) 100%
    • 1916A (1334) TUNISIA Five 5 Cent NGC MS 66 (TOP POP 1/0)
      1916A (1334) TUNISIA Five 5 Cent NGC MS 66 (TOP POP 1/0)
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $202.92
      or Best Offer
      +$13.46 delivery
      from United Kingdom
      Sponsored
      bargainwomble (871) 100%
    • CANADA Canadian 1916 25C NGC AU50 AU 50 Twenty-Five Cent Graded Certified Coin
      CANADA Canadian 1916 25C NGC AU50 AU 50 Twenty-Five Cent Graded Certified Coin
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $199.95
      Buy It Now
      +$5.95 delivery
      Sponsored
      leeward7 (45,466) 100%
    • 1916 BUFFALO Scarce 2 FEATHERS VARIETY FS-402 5C LOOK!! Only 2 graded by NGC!!
      1916 BUFFALO Scarce 2 FEATHERS VARIETY FS-402 5C LOOK!! Only 2 graded by NGC!!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $19.99
      Buy It Now
      +$3.99 delivery in 2-4 days
      Sponsored
      dayr5156 (12,269) 100%
    • ANTIQUE 1916 BUFFALO NICKEL NGC GRADED MS-63 BEAUTIFUL CONDITION MINT STATE...
      ANTIQUE 1916 BUFFALO NICKEL NGC GRADED MS-63 BEAUTIFUL CONDITION MINT STATE...
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $188.00
      Buy It Now
      +$8.00 delivery
      Sponsored
      codeecat (3,386) 98%
    • EGYPT, 1916H COPPER NICKEL 10 MILLIEMES. SULTAN HUSSEIN KAMEL. NGC MS 64. RARE.
      EGYPT, 1916H COPPER NICKEL 10 MILLIEMES. SULTAN HUSSEIN KAMEL. NGC MS 64. RARE.
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $299.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      ahmedelgamal007 (2,734) 100%
    • 1916 P NGC MS65 Buffalo Nickel
      1916 P NGC MS65 Buffalo Nickel
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $403.74
      Was: $424.995% off
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      coinslabz26 (11,298) 100%
    • EGYPT, 1916H COPPER NICKEL 10 MILLIEMES. SULTAN HUSSEIN KAMEL. NGC MS 63. RARE.
      EGYPT, 1916H COPPER NICKEL 10 MILLIEMES. SULTAN HUSSEIN KAMEL. NGC MS 63. RARE.
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $350.00
      or Best Offer
      +$30.00 delivery
      from United Arab Emirates
      Sponsored
      currencypalace (270) 100%
    • 1916 P NGC MS66 Buffalo Nickel
      1916 P NGC MS66 Buffalo Nickel
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $926.24
      Was: $974.995% off
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      coinslabz26 (11,298) 100%
    • 1916 P Buffalo Nickel AU 58 NGC Brown Label Beautiful Toning Free Ship!
      1916 P Buffalo Nickel AU 58 NGC Brown Label Beautiful Toning Free Ship!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $79.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      red_ronin_777 (1,460) 99.8%
    • 1916 P NGC MS66+ Buffalo Nickel
      1916 P NGC MS66+ Buffalo Nickel
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $1,424.99
      Was: $1,499.995% off
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      coinslabz26 (11,298) 100%
    • EGYPT, 1916H COPPER NICKEL 10 MILLIEMES. SULTAN HUSSEIN KAMEL. NGC MS 62. RARE.
      EGYPT, 1916H COPPER NICKEL 10 MILLIEMES. SULTAN HUSSEIN KAMEL. NGC MS 62. RARE.
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $99.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      ahmedelgamal007 (2,734) 100%
    • 1916 "D" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC AU58 #013 About Uncirculated ECC&C
      1916 "D" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC AU58 #013 About Uncirculated ECC&C
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $159.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      east_coast_coin_collectables_inc (14,978) 99.9%Visit east_coast_coin_collectables_inc eBay Store!
    • 1916 Panama 5 Centesimos Silver Coin XF Details NGC Low Mintage 5c KM-2
      1916 Panama 5 Centesimos Silver Coin XF Details NGC Low Mintage 5c KM-2
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $313.95
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      10 watchers
      Sponsored
      continentalcoinandjewelry (8,969) 100%
    • 1916-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC MS64
      1916-D Buffalo Nickel Type 2 5C NGC MS64
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $621.99
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      sarasotararecoingallery (9,158) 99.9%Visit sarasotararecoingallery eBay Store!
    • 1916 "P" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC MS65 #001 Gem BU Unc ECC&C, Inc.
      1916 "P" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC MS65 #001 Gem BU Unc ECC&C, Inc.
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $399.99
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      east_coast_coin_collectables_inc (14,978) 99.9%Visit east_coast_coin_collectables_inc eBay Store!
    • 1916 Buffalo Nickel NGC XF 40 Problem Free Coin 5C
      1916 Buffalo Nickel NGC XF 40 Problem Free Coin 5C
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $39.99
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      mkelsch2013 (4,261) 100%
    • 1916 D Buffalo Nickel NGC AU, Low Mintage, Semi-Key Date
      1916 D Buffalo Nickel NGC AU, Low Mintage, Semi-Key Date
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $150.00
      or Best Offer
      +$5.25 delivery
      Sponsored
      livermorecoinandbullion (4,463) 100%
    • 1916 S Buffalo Nickel NGC AU 53, Low Mintage, Semi-Key Date
      1916 S Buffalo Nickel NGC AU 53, Low Mintage, Semi-Key Date
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $170.00
      or Best Offer
      +$5.25 delivery
      Sponsored
      livermorecoinandbullion (4,463) 100%
    • 1916 D Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS 64
      1916 D Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC MS 64
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $535.80
      Was: $570.006% off
      Buy It Now
      +$1.99 delivery in 2-4 days
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      ingodwetrustcoinsandcurrency (27,073) 100%Visit ingodwetrustcoinsandcurrency eBay Store!
    • 1916-D Buffalo Nickel NGC XF45 Sharp! YTFM
      1916-D Buffalo Nickel NGC XF45 Sharp! YTFM
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $120.10
      Was: $133.4410% off
      or Best Offer
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      coinman_2000 (141,318) 99.9%Visit coinman_2000 eBay Store!
    • 1916 Buffalo Nickel NGC MS 64 - Bright
      1916 Buffalo Nickel NGC MS 64 - Bright
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $210.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      bjstamps (29,779) 99.8%Visit bjstamps eBay Store!
    • 1916-D Buffalo Nickel NGC MS 62
      1916-D Buffalo Nickel NGC MS 62
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $250.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      bjstamps (29,779) 99.8%Visit bjstamps eBay Store!
    • 1916-S Buffalo Nickel NGC MS65
      1916-S Buffalo Nickel NGC MS65
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $2,887.50
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      georges-beautiful-buffalos (1,224) 100%Visit georges-beautiful-buffalos eBay Store!
    • 1916-D 5C Buffalo Nickel -  Graded by NGC as XF 40
      1916-D 5C Buffalo Nickel - Graded by NGC as XF 40
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $81.75
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      imrichandfamous (2,699) 100%
    • 1916-D Buffalo Nickel 5C Coin. Certified NGC MS67 - RARE Top Pop 2/0 in MS67!
      1916-D Buffalo Nickel 5C Coin. Certified NGC MS67 - RARE Top Pop 2/0 in MS67!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $14,216.75
      Was: $14,965.005% off
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery in 2-4 days
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      eternitycoin (31,094) 99.9%
    • 1916 5C Buffalo Nickel - NGC AU55
      1916 5C Buffalo Nickel - NGC AU55
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $67.00
      Buy It Now
      +$4.51 delivery
      Sponsored
      ds-vet (1,139) 100%
    • 1916-D BUFFALO NICKEL NGC AU 53    005
      1916-D BUFFALO NICKEL NGC AU 53 005
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $135.00
      Was: $180.0025% off
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      f-j-coins-variety-store (11,404) 99.7%
    • 1916-D Buffalo Nickel 5C Denver Very Fine 5C NGC VF30
      1916-D Buffalo Nickel 5C Denver Very Fine 5C NGC VF30
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $54.50
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery in 2-4 days
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      casper641 (826) 100%
    • 1916 Barber Quarter NGC AU 55 Twenty Five Cent 25c Silver US Coin WHITE LUSTER!!
      1916 Barber Quarter NGC AU 55 Twenty Five Cent 25c Silver US Coin WHITE LUSTER!!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $275.00
      or Best Offer
      +$3.99 delivery
      Sponsored
      macgyversqualityconnections (3,919) 98.2%
    • 1916 No "F" Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC VF 30
      1916 No "F" Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC VF 30
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $135.00
      Buy It Now
      +$8.55 delivery
      Sponsored
      tftnumismatics (11,549) 99.9%
    • 1916 Buffalo Nickel MS-67 NGC
      1916 Buffalo Nickel MS-67 NGC
      Opens in a new window or tab
      Buy with confidence & Free Shipping from APMEX on eBay!
      $4,875.94
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Direct from APMEX
      Sponsored
      apmex (567,486) 99.2%Visit apmex eBay Store!
    • 1916 NGC AU58 Buffalo Nickel Maumee Valley Collection **Beautiful Specimen!* 095
      1916 NGC AU58 Buffalo Nickel Maumee Valley Collection **Beautiful Specimen!* 095
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $68.95
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery in 2-4 days
      Sponsored
      mgse (6,339) 100%
    • 1916 Doubled Die Obverse DDO FS-101 Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC G 06
      1916 Doubled Die Obverse DDO FS-101 Buffalo Nickel 5C NGC G 06
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $4,899.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery in 2-4 days
      Free returns
      Sponsored
      Top Rated Plus
      • Sellers with highest buyer ratings
      • Returns, money back
      • Ships in a business day with tracking
      Learn More
      Top Rated Plus
      ingodwetrustcoinsandcurrency (27,073) 100%Visit ingodwetrustcoinsandcurrency eBay Store!
    • 1916-D NGC F15 Buffalo Nickel **Nice Specimen** 223-037
      1916-D NGC F15 Buffalo Nickel **Nice Specimen** 223-037
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $32.95
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery in 2-4 days
      Sponsored
      mgse (6,339) 100%
    • 1916 Canada Five Cents NGC AU50 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL NOW!
      1916 Canada Five Cents NGC AU50 5C Coin PRICED TO SELL NOW!
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $49.91
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      herbscoinshop2 (6,954) 99.1%
    • 1916 Canada Canadian Silver Five Cent NGC MS 64  FREE SHIP MS 65 VALUE IS $1500
      1916 Canada Canadian Silver Five Cent NGC MS 64 FREE SHIP MS 65 VALUE IS $1500
      Opens in a new window or tab
      $295.00
      Buy It Now
      Free delivery
      Sponsored
      ccmmjr (2,630) 100%
    • 1916 Buffalo Nickel NGC XF 40 Problem Free Coin 5C
      1916 Buffalo Nickel NGC XF 40 Problem Free Coin 5C
      Opens in a new window or tab
      1916 · NGC · XF 40
      $39.99
      or Best Offer
      Sponsored
    • 1916 P NGC MS64 Buffalo Nickel 5c US Mint Coin 1916-P MS-64
      1916 P NGC MS64 Buffalo Nickel 5c US Mint Coin 1916-P MS-64
      Opens in a new window or tab
      1916 · NGC · MS 64
      $149.95
      or Best Offer
      Sponsored
    • Tell us what you think- opens in new window or tab
    • Results Pagination - Page 1

      1. 1
      2. 2
      Items Per Page
      • 120Items Per Page
      • 240Items Per Page

    • About eBay
    • Announcements
    • Community
    • Security Center
    • Seller Center
    • Policies
    • Affiliates
    • Help & Contact
    • Site Map
    Copyright © 1995-2025 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Accessibility, User Agreement, Privacy, Consumer Health Data, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies, CA Privacy Notice, Your Privacy Choices and AdChoice
    Copyright © 1995-2025 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved. Accessibility, User Agreement, Privacy, Consumer Health Data, Payments Terms of Use, Cookies, CA Privacy Notice, Your Privacy Choices and AdChoice